Why Today’s Inflation Doesn’t Dictate Tomorrow’s Returns?
Rasa Beiniute, Head of Investor Relations at Rontgen
With annual inflation in Lithuania exceeding 6%, some residents are beginning to hesitate about investing, fearing that returns will not outpace rising prices or will only barely beat them. The great paradox, however, is that high inflation has only “hurt” investments made a year ago and says almost nothing about real returns a year from now.
Lithuanian residents already understand that any form of investing, including bank deposits offering just a percent or two, at the very least helps reduce the negative effect of inflation on savings.
For many Lithuanians, the ideal scenario is usually an investment return that beats inflation by at least a few percentage points, allowing them to preserve and moderately grow their accumulated capital. In recent decades, however, this was achievable with bank deposits in only a handful of individual years. As a result, people have increasingly turned to more profitable options: investment property, funds, stocks, bonds, and crowdfunding.
This year, however, as a new wave of inflation has swept over Lithuania and the world, investors are facing a situation where even these options may fail to outpace annual price growth. Some people see these circumstances as unexpected but understandable, and so they stay loyal to their earlier choices. A certain share of investors are seeking even higher, double-digit returns from often exotic investment directions, even though financial experts unanimously agree that this means entering a zone of disproportionately high risk.
This year, though, another group of residents has also emerged: people who, in the face of higher inflation, choose simply not to invest or to pause investing they had already started. Put simply, their logic goes like this: “If inflation is at 6–7%, what’s the point of investing in options offering a 6–7% return?” Lately, such thoughts can be heard both from people with investment experience and from those who do not invest.
This logic is open to criticism on many counts. Investing in all cases at least reduces the impact of rising prices, and individual years of extraordinary inflation simply “happen”, as most experienced investors understand. Moreover, even normal inflation means that we inevitably “give up” a percentage point or two of real investment return.
Finally, investing is in most cases a long-term process that can last decades, where what matters is the long-term return and how it compares to inflation. We would probably struggle to find someone who has invested for a long time in time-tested instruments and failed to significantly outpace inflation.
Still, investors frightened by today’s inflation spike could be reassured by one simple exercise, or simply by one realization. Paradoxically, many people assessing their investment options compare the latest inflation figure, which reflects price growth over the past year, with a return they will only receive a year from now. In other words, the 6% annual inflation announced by state institutions means that a negative impact of exactly that size will be felt not by new investments, but by investments made exactly a year ago.
To put it another way, those who invested a year ago at a 6% annual interest rate have most likely “given up” their entire return to inflation. These investors, who made a rational decision at the time, could not have foreseen the conflict in the Middle East that began in February and the energy and inflation crisis that followed. Nevertheless, today’s inflation figures certainly do not mean that we will still have 6% inflation a year from now.
If only because of the base effect, inflation is likely to decline significantly as early as the first half of next year. For example, the Bank of Lithuania forecasts average annual inflation of 3.1% for 2027. That is the figure residents should compare against the real return of the investment projects offered to them. Simply put, a 6–7% interest rate a year from now will “compete” not with today’s reported 6–7% price growth over the past year, but with the inflation that will be measured twelve months from now.
Of course, none of this means that Lithuania and the world will not experience new shocks over the coming year that could fuel inflation. And in all cases, people’s wish to simply spend the money they have earned should be respected. Although it is also paradoxical that this year’s wave of inflation in Lithuania can partly be linked to residents’ decision to use their pension reform money for consumption rather than investing or saving.
However, inflation reflects the past and is in no way reflected in future investment results, which is why simply separating these two indicators would help people make more rational decisions.